October Inflation: Waller Puts 50 Basis Points on the Table

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Pixabay CC0 Public Domain

Although the prospects of an agreement between Iran and the U.S. have pushed Brent crude down to $92 per barrel, its lowest level since August, the October inflation reading has negatively impacted the 2-10 curve, which has flattened to 20 basis points, and added pressure on equity valuations. The effect was heightened by comments from Waller, and the market has consequently raised the probability of a 50 basis point hike at the Federal Reserve’s final meeting of the year.

The release of the U.S. October CPI once again placed inflation at the center of investors’ attention. Core CPI rose 0.3% month-over-month, versus 0.2% expected, thus stringing together 3 consecutive months at that pace. In annualized terms, 3-month core inflation accelerated to 3.75%, its highest level since April 2024. The headline figure was even stronger, with a monthly increase of 0.35% and a 3-month annualized pace of 5.72%. Furthermore, as highlighted by the Cleveland Fed’s trimmed-mean inflation indicator—which excludes the 8% of components with the largest increases and the 8% with the smallest, averaging the remaining items—the rebound was fairly widespread across the different components of the basket, making it difficult to interpret as a one-off episode or one concentrated in a few categories, and pointing to supply-side pressures beginning to filter through, particularly via higher transportation costs.

The market’s reaction was amplified by earlier remarks from Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller. Prior to the data release, he had indicated that if core CPI came in around 0.3% or higher once again, the Fed should consider a 50 basis point hike in December. He also warned that limiting the move to 25 basis points under that scenario could jeopardize the central bank’s credibility. When that exact 0.3% reading was confirmed, his remarks came to be perceived as a concrete possibility rather than a mere hypothesis.

As a result, the market went from pricing in 21 basis points of rate hikes for December on Monday to 28.5 basis points on Wednesday. This implies that a 25 basis point hike became fully priced in, while futures began assigning roughly a 14.9% probability to a more aggressive 50 basis point move. This shift in outlook also affected 12-month projections: on Monday the curve was pricing in 2 hikes through December 2027, and it is now approaching 3.

Why we do not expect a 50 basis point hike

What we are seeing is the volatility that traditionally accompanies a maturing economic cycle. While it is true that core inflation has posted 3 consecutive 0.3% readings (though unrounded, the latest stands at 0.296%) and annualizes at 3.7%, the year-over-year rate remains below 3% and the 6-month annualized pace sits at 2.7%. In addition, the real interest rate is already positive (~+0.8%) and, with the Treasury yield back at 5% and the dollar strengthening once again, financial conditions will tighten further. It should also be remembered that the cycle is advancing and the global backdrop is one of monetary policy tightening, which will weigh on industrial activity and moderate growth in the coming months.

Historically, 50 basis point hikes have occurred when the market had already priced them in. Since 1994, when the 2-year Treasury yield stood at least 1 percentage point above the policy rate, 43% of rate hikes were 50 basis points or larger; when it stood below that threshold, only 6% were. Today, the spread hovers around 0.7 percentage points.

With a spread below 1 percentage point, the conditional probability of a 50 basis point hike in December is just 6.5%, well below the share of hikes of that magnitude or greater since 1994 (21%, and only 12% when excluding the post-pandemic cycle of 2022).

Equities: adjusted multiples and favorable seasonality

The yield on the 10-year Treasury note has returned to 5.12%, pressuring equity multiples, which—nevertheless—have already adjusted to this effect and, unlike in the 1st quarter, show a slight undervaluation amid a backdrop of technical oversold conditions and investor pessimism. All of this coincides with highly favorable seasonality for shareholders and a moderation in volatility readings.

Dollar: short-term strength, medium-term structural weakness

The recalibration in rate-hike expectations has also impacted the dollar’s exchange rate. The DXY index rose 0.7% following the CPI release and maintains a clear upward trend. The growth and resilience of the U.S. economy compared to other developed economies, coupled with doubts over inflation, keep pressure on the short end of the curve and favor the greenback.

EURUSD attempted unsuccessfully to reclaim the 1.13 level, making clear that the dollar is the strong currency in the short term. Even if it were to break above that threshold, it would face significant technical resistance near 1.14.

Nevertheless, the euro appears 10% undervalued against the dollar on a purchasing power parity basis, and its medium-term trajectory is closely tied to that of artificial intelligence, given its weight in the performance of major equity indexes: net foreign purchases of U.S. equities have substantially underpinned the dollar over the past 10 months.

Redemptions Cool in Private Debt, Yet Liquidity Concerns Persist

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Pixabay CC0 Public Domain

At the intersection of demand that keeps growing across all investor segments and a supply increasingly interested in wealth channels—including Latin America, an area of special interest for a variety of asset managers—interesting developments are taking place in the market. Even though the echo of the redemption episode in private debt funds structured as BDCs (business development companies) is still being felt, the industry highlights the resilience of private credit and its strong performance. Still, that does not mean the debate surrounding liquidity matching is off the table.

“Managers find themselves caught between 2 powerful and contradictory trends. On one hand, investors are allocating more and more capital to private credit, infrastructure, and other private market strategies in search of yield and diversification. On the other hand, these same investors increasingly expect flexibility, transparency, and, in many cases, rapid access to their capital,” described Henri Coste, Head of Global Strategy for Asset Managers’ Services at BNP Paribas.

For the executive, this is the dynamic at the heart of the discussion around liquidity in private market assets. In that context, he added, the industry’s challenge is not only creating more liquidity, but managing expectations around the issue. “The winners are going to be the firms that can combine growth in private markets with robust liquidity governance, advanced risk analytics, and integrated treasury capabilities,” he commented in a recent note.

Thus, liquidity is no longer seen merely as a portfolio feature, but is positioning itself as a competitive advantage.

Looking at the space where the past year’s “noise” in the asset class originated—BDCs—flow dynamics remain negative. However, a detailed analysis of 3rd-quarter figures shows that the situation is calming down and that many of the divestments still pending carry over from prior quarters.

Redemptions are cooling down

Out of a portfolio of 15 non-traded BDCs, Fitch Ratings noted that 13 saw fewer redemption requests in the 3rd quarter than in the 2nd. Moreover, in the case of the 9 BDCs with requests above 5%, the firm revealed that a “significant percentage” reflects pending requests prorated from earlier quarters, rather than renewed appetite to divest.

Even so, the rating agency stressed that outflows remain relatively elevated compared to historical norms, averaging 9.8% of shares—and it expects that to remain the case.

Looking ahead, the rating agency anticipates that requests will continue declining over the coming quarters. “Requests are likely to remain elevated compared to pre-2026 levels, as firms continue working through previously prorated requests,” it stated in a report, adding that it believes “it will take several quarters for average requests to fall below 5%.”

Regardless, while the impact on capital raising is expected to persist for some time, Fitch views the sector as well positioned to weather the dynamic. According to the firm, the non-traded BDCs it analyzed “have sufficient liquidity to cover several quarters of redemptions at the cap.”

Added to this is the fact that, as the queue moves forward, fewer and fewer investors remain with pending redemptions. “The queue has been concentrated in international wealth, with smaller institutional investors and family offices, and it is shrinking quarter over quarter,” emphasized Michael Arougheti, CEO of Ares Management Corp, on the firm’s latest earnings call. “Core individual private clients with good advice are not showing elevated redemption activity,” he added, noting that the asset manager posted its 2nd-best quarter in its wealth business.

The appeal of the asset class

In that sense, the industry describes the asset class as resilient, viewing the situation among retail clients in private debt funds more as a mismatch than a canary in the coal mine. For the same reason, top executives at several asset managers operating private credit BDC vehicles recently hailed the resilience of the asset class and the strength of demand in the institutional channel.

At BlackRock—which also operates a sizable private debt BDC—CFO Martin Small sees positive momentum ahead. “I am more optimistic that we are going to start seeing evergreen private market funds enter a new phase in the 4th quarter and the 1st half of next year,” the executive remarked on a call with investors and analysts. And, considering the flow dynamics they have observed, that new chapter has already begun.

In that vein, Small described private credit performance as “resilient.” While pending redemptions remain and levels are still elevated, the executive emphasized that conversations with distributors are proving “constructive.”

Apollo Global Management shares that view. Following a 3rd quarter in which it raised $4B across its global wealth business, the firm’s President and Director, James Charles Zelter, gave a vote of confidence to the asset class. “Direct private credit, which has faced plenty of questioning regarding its durability this year, is performing well for us,” he said, adding that “the answer is the returns.”

Furthermore, the strength of institutional demand adds another piece to the puzzle. Blue Owl reported a record quarter in its institutional business, with that segment accounting for nearly 3/4 of capital raised over the past 12 months. As for the wealth channel, the firm’s CFO, Alan Kirshenbaum, noted on the quarterly call that they continue “seeing a bifurcation in flow trends between non-traded BDC products and our other wealth-focused products.”

ETFs Grow 90% in Brazil, Driven by Fixed Income

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Photo courtesy

ETF assets in Brazil grew nearly 90% in the first 10 months of 2026, surpassing 156B reais (over $27.5B), driven by the expansion of fixed-income index funds. According to ANBIMA data, volume rose from 82.7B in December 2025 to 156.9B reais in October, an increase of 74.1B reais (around $13.07B).

Fixed income accounted for roughly 62% of that increase. Assets in fixed-income ETFs jumped from 30.1B to 75.8B reais, a 152.3% surge. With this, their industry share grew from 36.3% to 48.3%, approaching half of all assets under management.

For Anderson Moreira, investment specialist and Head of Content at DEX, the movement combines Brazilian investors’ familiarity with fixed income, the expansion of available strategies, and the growth of fee-based compensation models tied to advisory or consulting services.

In the specialist’s view, fixed income enables broader ETF adoption by building on an exposure Brazilian investors already know. Growth is supported by the combination of asset familiarity, market volatility, and a wider product offering from asset managers.

“The Brazilian investor is very accustomed to this fixed-income dynamic. So, like it or not, having the ability to access something that is already in the Brazilian investor’s DNA through an ETF are factors that end up reinforcing one another,” he states.

According to Moreira, the fee-based model also encourages discussions around ETFs by reducing the influence of product commissions on portfolio construction.

“They are no longer concerned about the commission a given product will generate; they end up having more incentive to look toward long-term construction, toward the portfolio, toward the client’s objective,” he says. For Moreira, this shift opens room to discuss a more structured allocation, as the advisor’s compensation becomes less dependent on the specific product suggested by the institution.

Under ANBIMA’s classification, ETFs were the fund category with the highest percentage asset growth in the industry between December 2025 and October 2026: 89.6%. Next came Fiagros, with a 49.2% rise. Fixed income grew 13.8%; real estate funds, 13.2%; pension funds, 10.3%; and equity funds, 5.6%. Meanwhile, multimarket funds declined 3.9%. The comparison considers the association’s fund categories: ETFs can encompass both fixed-income and equity strategies.

Inflows accompany growth

Asset expansion was accompanied by net inflows. Between January and October, ETFs took in 58.7B net reais (around $10.35B), of which 38.1B went to fixed income and 20.6B to equities, according to ANBIMA.

Equity ETFs also expanded their assets, from 52.7B to 81B reais, a 53.9% gain. Although they grew less proportionally, they still held the largest share of assets at the close of October.

The distinction between asset growth and net inflows is important: total assets reflect both subscriptions and redemptions as well as fluctuations in asset values. Therefore, the 74.1B real increase does not correspond entirely to new money.

Moreira notes that a drop in share price can even occur at the same time a fund is receiving inflows.

“You can have appreciation in the ETF while experiencing redemptions, and vice versa—you can have a decline in the ETF while receiving investments, because at the end of the day you are tracking an index,” he states.

Examining flows, the specialist highlighted that mark-to-market effects had not interrupted inflows across different strategies. “Even with movements along the interest rate curve, we have observed various ETFs—both Smart Selic and government bond, inflation, and fixed-rate ETFs—posting significant inflow volumes.”

ETFs gain ground at major asset managers

Among the country’s 5 largest asset managers by total fund assets, Itaú held the largest ETF volume in ANBIMA’s September ranking: 39.3B reais. Following within that group were BTG Pactual, with 23B, and Bradesco, with 20.5B.

Between December 2025 and September 2026, ETF assets grew 177.1% at Bradesco, 152.2% at BTG, 84% at BB, and 49.3% at Itaú. At Caixa, they fell 53.9%.

In cumulative net inflows from January to September, BTG recorded 11.4B reais in ETFs, followed by Bradesco with 10.3B, and Itaú with approximately 10B.

For Moreira, the expanded offering also reflects a commercial strategy by asset managers. Launching proprietary versions of fixed-income ETFs allows them to compete for the allocations of clients already within their distribution channels.

“We have seen various firms creating their own version of Smart Selic, even 100% LFT, to be able to keep that money in-house,” he states. Comparing product growth, he emphasizes that “each firm has its own shareholder base, its own distribution strategy.”

Also a tool for institutional investors

The specialist identifies ETF applications that extend beyond retail investor purchases. Pension funds and active fund managers can use the structure to implement portfolio exposures, with the support of market makers. In his assessment, the ability to negotiate entry and exit—including spread conditions—contributes to this adoption.

“You don’t just have pension funds, you also have actively managed funds themselves that may end up making an entry via an ETF,” he says. “There are funds that end up making moves in this space, whether to gain direct exposure, execute a derivative, a hedge, or something else.”

Smart Selic requires attention to mark-to-market

Smart Selic strategies combine a predominant allocation to floating-rate securities with a smaller position in long-term inflation-linked bonds. This composition requires attention to the portfolio’s sensitivity to interest rate changes.

Moreira points out that the product can serve as an opportunity reserve, but its behavior differs from an investment aimed exclusively at day-to-day cash needs.

“It is money you are going to leave idle for a while, and there you want more controlled risk, except it is not daily cash risk. It carries an extra dose of risk,” he states. Moreira links this difference to the presence of long-term inflation-linked bonds in the portfolio, which increases the product’s sensitivity to interest rate movements.

During periods when the yield curve steepens, longer-dated bonds can suffer mark-to-market devaluation and negatively affect the ETF’s share price. Suitability, therefore, depends on the investor’s time horizon and liquidity needs.

“In these moments of sharp upward shifts in interest rates, when you have a longer duration and the curve widens, you get a very negative mark-to-market,” he explains. The specialist stresses that this fluctuation must be part of the conversation with the client prior to allocation: “Can Smart Selic be advantageous? It can, depending on your client’s allocation, yes, except that in moments of sharp upward moves in forward rates, this is the negative impact you are going to experience.”

Another operational feature of fixed-income ETFs is tax withholding at the source, which exempts investors from calculating and remitting capital gains taxes on their own for these trades. In Moreira’s view, this simplicity helps lower a barrier to entry, given recurring confusion over tax settlement and payment.

“You don’t need to issue a DARF, you don’t need to worry about calculating your average cost basis to settle your gain and compute your tax,” he says. “There is a great deal of confusion between filing taxes and paying taxes. So this taxation issue creates a certain friction for the Brazilian investor.”

Constant duration opens new possibilities

The expansion of fixed-income ETFs also involves developing strategies that allow investors to calibrate yield curve exposure. Moreira highlights constant-duration funds, which adjust their portfolios to keep rate sensitivity close to a defined level.

“When you buy a constant-duration ETF, that duration is locked at a specific level,” he states. Explaining the portfolio effect, he emphasizes the relationship between duration and interest rate sensitivity: “Your sensitivity to the interest rate curve is locked right there. It isn’t shifting dynamically, as happens, for example, in IMAB11. So you are better able to define what level of risk you want to be exposed to.”

The mechanism makes it possible to combine different duration buckets within a portfolio according to the allocation goal. Rather than tracking a sensitivity that shifts with the composition of a broad index, the investor selects exposure close to their target range.

The proposition is to allow allocators to choose and combine curve-sensitivity ranges rather than relying solely on the resulting duration of a broad basket of securities. “Whether you want more exposure to lower or higher sensitivity, a shorter or longer duration,” he illustrates. “You can calibrate the exact duration you want.”

In private credit, on the other hand, Moreira identifies additional hurdles to ETF expansion. Among them are bond liquidity, market-maker activity, and constraints on adjusting a portfolio that must track an index during a credit event.

“The big issue here is liquidity, because how is the market maker going to operate in a security that doesn’t trade on screen, an over-the-counter trade?” he asks.

The difficulty takes on another dimension when trouble arises with an issuer. An ETF manager must follow index rules when adjusting exposure, which, in Moreira’s assessment, narrows their room to maneuver. “Another point for private credit is when you have a credit risk episode. Then, how do you rebalance the portfolio? Because you still have to track the index,” he notes.

For the specialist, fixed income should continue seeing new launches, accompanied by a diversification of equity strategies and international exposure.

“Still, considering the backdrop we have, which should remain in place for some time longer, it is to be expected that we will see new launches in fixed income,” he states. The specialist ties this expectation to the outlook for interest rates remaining in double digits.

This environment coexists with the search for new methodologies in equity ETFs and more diversified international exposures. “We also observe a focus on more global strategies—not just the United States, but the world,” he says. To illustrate equity innovation, Moreira cites indexes that phase companies in and out gradually during rebalancings. “You don’t miss the move, particularly the upward move,” he says of this methodological approach.

Nomura and Aventus Create Misura, an Investment Management Platform for Securitized Products and Private Credit

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Canva

Nomura and Aventus (TSXV: AVTS), an integrated insurance and alternative asset management company backed by CC Capital, have launched a joint venture designed to offer investors access to differentiated opportunities, primarily in securitized products and private credit.

Through Misura, clients gain access to end-to-end asset sourcing and origination, alongside specialized investment advisory and portfolio management. This collaboration uniquely leverages the capabilities of Nomura’s renowned securitized products and private credit franchise to create bespoke capital solutions, combining them with Aventus’s expertise in underwriting and managing credit investments, as well as the extensive track record of its sponsor, CC Capital.

“This partnership brings together the agility and capabilities of a specialized investment manager with the origination reach of a global investment bank to create a highly differentiated credit platform. In a market where origination, structuring expertise, and investment discipline are decisive, we believe our complementary strengths provide a solid foundation for an enduring business that builds upon the CC Capital and Aventus platform and positions it to capture attractive opportunities across both the full credit spectrum and special situations,” stated Chinh Chu, Founder and Senior Managing Director of CC Capital and Executive Chairman of Aventus.

For his part, Chris Willcox, Deputy President, Head of Wholesale, and Chair of the Investment Management Division at Nomura, noted: “Expanding our securitized products and private markets solutions business is a top strategic priority, and through this joint venture, we have succeeded in broadening our footprint by leveraging the scale of Nomura’s franchise alongside Aventus’s investment management capabilities. We are pleased to collaborate with the CC Capital and Aventus teams on the launch of Misura.”

Regarding the alliance, Gordon Sweely, Head of Securitized Products and Private Credit at Nomura, commented: “Misura brings together Nomura’s industry-leading expertise, global reach, and specialized focus to deliver tailored financing solutions to clients. This partnership expands our distribution capabilities across the entire capital structure, enabling us to bring Nomura’s premier platform to a broader client base.”

And Andrew Rabinowitz, Chief Executive Officer of Misura Asset Management, concluded: “We have built a platform that combines specialized investment talent, proven across multiple market cycles, with a large-scale origination engine, while preserving independence in underwriting and investment decision-making. I am excited about what Nomura and Aventus can create together, and I thank the entire Nomura team for their pivotal role in developing the platform.”

When Private Life Shakes Wall Street

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Photo courtesy

From Nvidia to McDonald’s, Intel, and Nestlé, romantic scandals, conflicts of interest, and the personal conduct of top executives have demonstrated that a company’s reputation can also rest in the hands of whoever occupies the corner office.

The fall of Jensen Huang not only represents an unexpected episode in Nvidia’s history, but also places back on the table one of the most delicate issues in corporate governance: how far does a CEO’s private life extend when personal decisions can compromise the interests of a company, its shareholders, and thousands of employees?

Private life, yet public

The answer is not simple, yet there is something that large corporations are increasingly clear about: the conduct of the person holding the top executive position is not an exclusively personal matter when it can generate conflicts of interest, call into question the enforcement of internal rules, or compromise the organization’s reputation.

The case of Huang, who stepped down this Thursday, November 12, from the presidency, chief executive role, and his seat on Nvidia’s board of directors after 33 years at the helm of the company, constitutes a particularly illustrative example.

The departure occurred after the businessman publicly acknowledged having been unfaithful to his wife and reports surfaced regarding romantic relationships allegedly involving a woman suspected of maintaining ties to Chinese intelligence services and a Nvidia executive who, according to media reports, reported directly to him. The company had previously opened an independent investigation and retained external legal counsel. Although the resignation statement did not expressly attribute the decision to a specific cause, the sequence of events turned the personal episode into a corporate governance and reputational crisis.

Investor reaction was immediate. Nvidia shares plunged around 14% during early trading on Thursday, November 12, touching an intraday low of $148.80 before ultimately closing at $166.19, down 4.34%.

The company, whose market capitalization hovers around $4.2T, had to announce that Colette Kress, until then Chief Financial Officer, would assume the interim chief executive role while the board searches for a permanent successor. The market reacted not only to the departure of one of the most influential figures of the artificial intelligence revolution, but also to the uncertainty entailed by losing the man who built much of the company’s technological and strategic identity.

Other corporate scandals

The case of Nvidia’s CEO is not inaugurating a new category of corporate scandal. In fact, one of the closest precedents occurred at Intel in 2018, when Brian Krzanich had to resign as CEO after an internal investigation confirmed he had engaged in a consensual relationship with an employee, in violation of the company’s non-fraternization policy applicable to all executives.

The board’s decision was decisive: if the rest of the workforce was obligated to respect internal rules, the company’s top executive could not place himself above them. The similarity to the Nvidia episode is evident: the corporate problem does not necessarily consist of passing judgment on a romantic relationship, but rather determining whether a reporting relationship, a conflict of interest, or a breach of the rules meant to guarantee impartiality in business decisions exists.

A year later, in 2019, McDonald’s faced a similar situation. Its then-CEO, Steve Easterbrook, was fired after the company discovered he was engaged in a consensual romantic relationship with an employee, something prohibited by its internal policies.

However, the matter did not end with his departure. A subsequent investigation revealed other undisclosed relationships with employees and raised questions regarding the information he had provided to the company. The case escalated to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which in 2023 sanctioned the former executive for making false or misleading statements to investors regarding the circumstances of his termination.

It also scrutinized McDonald’s disclosure of his separation agreement, which had allowed him to retain compensation exceeding $40M. The company ultimately recovered approximately $105M in cash and stock. The lesson extended far beyond infidelity: concealing information, manipulating internal processes, or prioritizing personal interests can turn into an issue directly tied to shareholder protection.

More recently, in September 2025, Nestlé fired its CEO Laurent Freixe after confirming he was maintaining an undisclosed romantic relationship with a direct subordinate, in violation of its code of business conduct.

The investigation took place following internal complaints related to potential preferential treatment toward the employee. The episode underscored that integrity policies are not merely compliance mechanisms for operational tiers: they can also determine the tenure of a multinational’s top executive. And, above all, that the issue takes on another dimension when a personal relationship can influence promotions, compensation, evaluations, or decisions regarding company resources.

Loss of trust and other scandals, the blow to corporate culture

Nevertheless, romantic relationships represent only part of a much broader list of behaviors that have ended up shaking major corporations and eroding market confidence.

Volkswagen was at the center of one of the largest industrial scandals of recent decades with the so-called Dieselgate, uncovered in 2015, when it was revealed that the automaker had used software to manipulate emissions tests on its diesel vehicles. The crisis triggered the resignation of its then-CEO, Martin Winterkorn, in addition to fines, settlements, and a deterioration of its global reputation. In this instance it was not a matter of romantic conduct, but rather business decisions that compromised an organization’s ethics, transparency, and accountability toward its customers and regulators.

Enron represents another of the most forceful examples of how ambition and an absence of controls can destroy corporate trust. The U.S. energy giant collapsed in 2001 after complex accounting practices, debt concealment, and manipulation of its financial results came to light.

Its top executives, among them Kenneth Lay and Jeffrey Skilling, became associated with one of the largest corporate frauds in U.S. history. The bankruptcy wiped out thousands of jobs and retirement savings belonging to workers and investors. The case made clear that a company can project an image of success, innovation, and growth for years while its top leaders erode from within the very principles meant to sustain it.

There is also the case of Wells Fargo, where the opening of millions of bank accounts without customer authorization, driven by aggressive sales targets and high-pressure practices placed on employees, led to a crisis of confidence that culminated in the departure of its CEO, John Stumpf, in 2016.

Uber, for its part, saw its corporate culture falter under the leadership of Travis Kalanick, amid allegations of harassment, management failures, and scrutiny over the workplace environment, until he stepped down as chief executive in 2017. These are distinct episodes, yet they share a common thread: when an organization’s culture ceases to align with the principles it proclaims, the cost ultimately transfers to its reputation, its ability to attract talent, and the confidence of its investors.

What unites these cases is not necessarily the nature of the infractions, but the position of those at the center of them. A CEO is not just another employee. A CEO manages other people’s capital, represents the organization before the markets, participates in strategic decisions, and bears a special responsibility in building a culture of integrity.

For that reason, romantic relationships with subordinates, undisclosed conflicts of interest, abuse of power, manipulation of information, accounting fraud, or the concealment of problems cannot be analyzed solely from a personal standpoint. At a publicly traded company, any of those behaviors can carry financial, legal, and reputational consequences.

The issue is also tied to a paradox of corporate leadership: companies routinely demand strict levels of compliance, transparency, and accountability from their employees, yet when irregularities involve their top executives, boards of directors face a far more complex test. They must decide whether to protect a figure who may be vital to the business or uphold the rules, even when doing so means losing a founder, a successful executive, or the person who publicly represents the company. Nvidia has just confronted that dilemma, and its decision will carry consequences reaching far beyond Huang’s succession.

Ultimately, Wall Street can forgive strategic missteps, quarterly earnings below expectations, or even misguided investment decisions if there is a reasonable explanation and a path to recovery. What proves far harder to restore is trust when investors begin questioning the integrity of those leading a company.

The private life of a CEO should be, in principle, precisely that: private. Yet when personal decisions compromise impartiality, safety, transparency, or compliance with corporate rules, it ceases to be so. Nvidia, Intel, McDonald’s, and Nestlé, to name a few cases, serve as reminders that at major corporations power also entails obligations. No CEO, however successful or indispensable they may appear, should stand above them. The market knows it, and the market remembers.

From the Playing Field to the World of Investments: The Formula for Success Does Not Change

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Photo courtesy

What do a goalkeeper who played in 6 World Cups and a golfer who reached the 6th spot in the world rankings have in common? At first glance, their stories seem to belong exclusively to professional sports. However, their experiences offer lessons that also have a place in financial markets, business, and investment strategies: talent can open doors, but it is discipline, perseverance, and the ability to make decisions that allow one to stay at the top.

That was the essence of 2 conversations that Guillermo Ochoa and Anthony Kim held on October 28 during a gathering organized by the Milken Institute in Mexico City. Although their careers unfolded in different disciplines and their personal circumstances were vastly different, both agreed on a fundamental idea: success is not a final destination, but a process that demands preparation, learning, and the capacity to get back up after every setback.

The reflections of the former Mexican goalkeeper, whose career spanned more than 2 decades and took him to 6 World Cups, and of the American golfer, who reached the international elite before turning 25 and later faced a prolonged personal and professional crisis, make it possible to draw a parallel with the world of investing. In both arenas, outcomes depend as much on preparation as on how risk is managed, uncertainty is confronted, and mistakes are answered.

Memo Ochoa: building wealth also demands discipline and long-term vision

For Guillermo Ochoa, the end of his cycle as a professional footballer did not mean abandoning competition, but rather transferring what he learned over more than 22 years into a new stage: business, investments, and building a legacy. In conversation with Juan Manuel Valle, CEO of Afore Coppel, the former goalkeeper explained that one of his priorities after taking a period of rest was to become more directly involved in managing the wealth he had built during his career. A decision that, as he recounted, did not arise spontaneously, since during his years as a footballer he had sought to diversify his income streams and prepare for the moment he left the pitch.

Ochoa brought up a reality that often goes unnoticed in professional sports: athletes begin generating substantial income at very young ages, yet their earning capacity also ends much earlier than that of other professionals. As an example, he noted that a footballer typically experiences their peak earning years between ages 20 and 40, whereas other professionals may reach their highest economic capacity between ages 40 and 60 or 65. That difference forces athletes to think ahead about their financial future and understand that a high salary does not necessarily equate to solid wealth.

His strategy consisted of advancing gradually. He began with mutual funds, bonds, and fixed-income products, both short- and long-term; later he moved toward emerging companies and startups, in some cases through partnerships in which he participates as a partner rather than merely as a commercial brand ambassador. He also incorporated real estate investments and protection mechanisms such as life and major medical insurance.

The former national team player acknowledged that not all of his investments worked out. He recalled unsuccessful experiences in businesses such as gas stations, pyramid schemes, and startups, including a video game from which he expected substantial growth. Nevertheless, he emphasized that those missteps allowed him to identify risks, learn to evaluate opportunities better, and distrust proposals that promise extraordinary returns.

His philosophy, he explained, remains conservative. First he sought to build a solid wealth foundation and, once a degree of stability was achieved, began considering higher-risk investments. Experience also taught him to recognize when an opportunity does not match his profile and when it is better to stay on the sidelines of volatility. In that sense, he summed up one of his main financial lessons in a simple recommendation: save consistently and avoid unnecessary expenses.

Yet perhaps Ochoa’s most relevant reflection went beyond his own experience. He considered that Mexican sports has unfinished business in financial education, as many athletes do not know how to manage their income, where to invest, how to protect their wealth, or whom to turn to for specialized advice. He warned that some athletes end up losing their resources just a few years after earning them, whether due to lack of knowledge, investing in businesses they do not understand, or trusting the wrong people.

Consequently, he proposed fostering a culture of saving and wealth management starting at the youth development stages, incorporating tools to plan for retirement, purchase insurance, invest in real estate, and receive tax and financial advisory services. His purpose in this new chapter, he explained, is to help close those gaps through projects combining sports, education, technology, and business.

His closing reflection captured the shift in priorities: after dedicating a large part of his life to guarding a goal, he now wants to protect his family’s wealth and build a legacy that enables others to go further.

Anthony Kim: after hitting rock bottom, the importance of starting over

Anthony Kim’s story offers another perspective on perseverance and the ability to rebuild oneself. The American golfer, who rose to 6th in the world rankings before turning 25, enjoyed a meteoric career, yet also went through a particularly difficult personal period that kept him away from professional golf for more than 12 years.

In his conversation with Rodrigo Bettini, Managing Director at the Milken Institute, Kim recalled that his introduction to golf began when he was barely 2.5 years old, in an immigrant family whose parents held high expectations for his future. Behind his athletic upbringing was, above all, his mother’s sacrifice, having worked for years without vacations or days off to offer him opportunities she herself had never had.

That effort was one of his primary motivations. Kim acknowledged that much of his career was driven by the desire to repay his family’s sacrifices and enable his mother to stop working.

However, success arrived much faster than he was prepared to handle. Before receiving his first PGA Tour paycheck, he recalled, he was living on a futon in his coach’s basement and had barely $50 in his bank account. Then came the endorsements, the money, the recognition, and an environment in which, as he recounted, too many people told him everything he did was right. A lack of boundaries, bad company, and struggles with addiction and mental health ultimately led him into a dark period that kept him away from the sport for more than a decade.

Today, at 41 years old, sober and with a renewed outlook on life, Kim considers one of his greatest lessons to be understanding the importance of personal relationships and listening to those who genuinely want to help him. He admitted that in the past he pushed away people who pointed out his mistakes, while keeping close others who took advantage of his moments of vulnerability.

Rehabilitation also enabled him to develop a philosophy he now applies both to his personal life and to his return to professional golf: getting 1% better every day. Rather than focusing exclusively on major outcomes or goals difficult to control, Kim learned to set small, achievable objectives. It might mean spending several hours perfecting a shot, practicing putts, or completing a training session. What matters, he explained, is fulfilling the established purpose, regardless of whether immediate results are favorable.

That mindset also reshaped his relationship with defeat. He recalled that in his first tournament after returning to the LIV Golf circuit, he finished in last place, 33 strokes behind the leaders over 3 rounds. Although he admitted he remains a sore loser, he now understands that the outcome of a competition does not define a person’s worth nor should it become an obstacle to pressing forward.

His comeback, moreover, is driven by different motivations than his first stint as a professional. Sobriety, his wife, and especially his daughter gave him a different perspective on life’s priorities. Golf remains important, but being present for his family now comes first.

Kim also offered a recommendation for young athletes striving to reach the highest level: before focusing exclusively on winning, they need to build a foundation of personal stability they can fall back on when things go wrong. It is a lesson that can also be carried over into any professional field. Having a solid structure, surrounding oneself with trustworthy people, and developing habits that help navigate difficult moments can be just as important as talent or the opportunities that arise along the way.

Two disciplines, one shared lesson for investors

The experiences of Ochoa and Kim show that success takes different expressions, yet shares certain fundamentals. In sports, as in investing, talent and initial resources do not guarantee sustainable results. Discipline is needed to prepare, patience to wait for outcomes, intelligence to manage risks, and humility to acknowledge mistakes. Ochoa represents the importance of anticipating the future. He understood that his athletic career had an expiration date and that he needed to build wealth capable of sustaining his lifestyle beyond the pitch. His experience also demonstrates that diversifying, seeking advice, and not being seduced by extraordinary returns are fundamental decisions for protecting capital.

Kim, for his part, represents the capacity to rebuild. His trajectory serves as a reminder that even those who reach extraordinary heights can lose their way, and that coming back requires recognizing mistakes, changing habits, and establishing new priorities. His philosophy of improving 1% daily is, in essence, a wager on sustained growth rather than the pursuit of immediate results.

For an investor or a financial strategist, both stories carry a particularly valuable takeaway. The first is that generating resources is not enough: one must manage, protect, and grow them with a long-term vision. The second is that mistakes are part of the process, but the difference lies in learning from them and preventing them from becoming behavioral patterns.

There is also a lesson regarding one’s environment. Neither of them built his trajectory entirely alone. Ochoa recognized the importance of having advisors and people to guide him in his wealth decisions; Kim learned, after a difficult period, that surrounding oneself with people capable of telling the truth is indispensable to staying on course. In financial markets, where uncertainty, volatility, and high-pressure decisions are part of daily activity, those qualities take on special value. Knowing when to advance, when to wait, when to take on risk, and, above all, when to recognize that a decision was mistaken can make the difference between a successful strategy and a loss difficult to recover from.

In the end, the stories shared at the Milken Institute gathering left a reflection that transcends pitches and golf courses: true success does not consist solely of reaching the top, but of developing the ability to stay there, adapt when circumstances change, and find new reasons to keep moving forward. And perhaps that is the greatest overlap between a high-performance athlete and a good investor: both know that major victories are rarely built in a single day.

Retirement No Longer Has an Expiration Date, Longevity Forces a Reinvention of Pensions and Investments: Encuentro Amafore 2026

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Photo courtesy

The pension industry is facing a paradigm shift: longevity, labor market transformation, and the technological revolution are forcing a rethink not only of how much workers must save, but also of how their assets are invested and, above all, how they are converted into income capable of sustaining them through longer retirement periods.

That was one of the main conclusions of the first day of Encuentro Amafore 2026, where national and international specialists agreed that the future of pension systems will depend on their ability to adapt to a reality in which living longer will be increasingly common, yet also more costly from a financial standpoint.

The challenge takes on particular relevance for Mexico, where the Retirement Savings System (SAR) already manages more than 9.3T pesos (around $509B), an asset pool that represents an opportunity to strengthen pensions, expand financing for productive projects, and contribute to economic growth, always under criteria of profitability, security, and fiduciary responsibility.

The discussion began with a warning about what could become humanity’s next major revolution. David Sinclair, a Harvard scientist specializing in longevity, anticipated that following artificial intelligence, the next major shift will be tied to extending healthy lifespans, driven by scientific and technological advances.

The consequence extends far beyond medicine: if people live longer and retain their physical and intellectual capacities for more years, they will also have to modify their career, financial, and wealth decisions. In other words, retirement systems designed for a shorter life expectancy will have to respond to a completely different reality.

The problem, therefore, is not limited to getting workers to accumulate more money during their working lives. It will also be necessary to ensure that those resources last to finance a retirement that could span several decades. Matthew Michelini, President of Athene, placed the emphasis precisely on that transition: pension systems must stop treating accumulation and decumulation as independent processes.

His proposition is that investment strategies must factor in from the outset how savings will be transformed into income during retirement. “Accumulation and decumulation strategies have to be combined,” he argued, warning that the true challenge lies in designing solutions that allow pension wealth to be converted into a sufficient and sustainable source of income.

Yet before thinking about how to spend accumulated resources, another obstacle stands in the way: keeping them invested for the necessary duration. David Laibson, behavioral economist and Harvard professor, pointed out that mechanisms such as automatic enrollment and automatic contributions help foster saving, though they lose effectiveness when workers make early withdrawals or face immediate financial needs.

For Mexico, the specialist deemed it necessary to develop instruments that protect long-term savings and allow informal workers to be brought into the fold. To that end, digital payment platforms could become a tool to broaden participation and facilitate contributions to the pension system.

From retirement savings to productive investment

The other major discussion of the gathering centered on the destination of pension assets and their capacity to become an investment lever for the country.

With more than 9.3T pesos under management, the SAR represents one of Mexico’s largest pools of institutional savings. María del Carmen Bonilla Rodríguez, Undersecretary of Finance, highlighted that an opportunity exists to channel a greater proportion of those assets toward productive projects, provided they feature legal certainty, technical viability, and attractive returns for workers.

The official put a fundamental principle on the table: economic development and pension sustainability must not be understood as opposing objectives. However, for both to advance, Afore participation must preserve the administrators’ fiduciary responsibility, as well as establish appropriate risk-sharing frameworks.

The discussion is particularly relevant because the growth of pension assets requires finding new investment opportunities without sacrificing the return and security objectives that must prevail in managing workers’ resources.

Against this backdrop, artificial intelligence is beginning to reshape the opportunity map for institutional investors. Reid Menge, Co-Portfolio Manager of Global Technology at BlackRock, explained that this revolution is driving investments in compute infrastructure, energy, data centers, robotics, and healthcare.

Nevertheless, he warned that energy availability could become one of the main bottlenecks to sustaining technological expansion. This means the race to capitalize on artificial intelligence will not be limited to companies developing models and applications, but will also involve the sectors capable of providing the infrastructure necessary for its operation.

Technological transformation compounds other factors reshaping investment decisions: economic fragmentation, geopolitical tensions, and market concentration. Specialists from CME Group, Barclays, Janus Henderson, and Veritas agreed that this environment compels investors to review their diversification strategies across regions, sectors, and asset classes.

Rob Lovelace, President of Capital International and portfolio manager at Capital Group, warned that market concentration reinforces the importance of maintaining a long-term perspective and active management capable of distinguishing between sustainable opportunities and cyclical swings.

For pension funds, whose investment horizon can span several decades, avoiding hasty decisions in the face of volatility episodes will be decisive in protecting return targets.

Financial infrastructure also enters the equation

Market modernization constitutes another element of the pension agenda. Jorge Alegría, CEO of Grupo BMV, highlighted progress in strengthening clearing and settlement processes in Mexico’s bond market, while Tannia Munroe of Tradeweb underscored that electronic trading and central clearing can help improve liquidity and reduce operating costs.

The international discussion also reached the political arena. David Agnew, Managing Director at Macquarie Group, noted that the results of the U.S. midterm elections will carry implications for investment decisions, particularly in sectors such as energy, infrastructure, and data centers, where state government policies and regulations can prove decisive.

On the pension front, the overarching assessment was that Mexico possesses a well-positioned system, yet still faces significant pending tasks regarding pension coverage and adequacy.

During the panel The Future of Pensions: A Global Perspective, Amy Barklam, His Majesty’s Trade Commissioner for Latin America and the Caribbean, maintained that reforms must be evaluated by the outcomes they generate for savers and not solely by the regulatory changes they introduce.

For his part, André Maxnuk, CEO of Marsh México, recognized the strength of the Mexican system in terms of sustainability and funding, though he identified coverage as one of the areas where room for improvement remains.

In parallel, the event’s agenda incorporated a gender perspective within the financial industry. The Interinstitutional Committee for Gender Equality in Financial Entities presented advances in narrowing gaps, increasing female participation in executive roles, and building safe workplaces.

During the meeting, Finance Secretary Édgar Amador Zamora called for extending these efforts nationwide. The body also announced a permanent collaboration with UN Women and the handover of its presidency, which will be assumed by Amafore over the coming year following the term led by Amsofipo.

The takeaway from the first day of Encuentro Amafore 2026 leaves a conclusion that transcends fund administrators and financial markets: the future of pensions will depend on more than increasing individual account balances. It will be necessary to expand the saver base, prevent resources from being withdrawn prematurely, diversify investments, and build mechanisms capable of financing a longer retirement.

The SAR’s 9.3T pesos represent an extraordinary opportunity for Mexico, yet also a responsibility of enormous proportions. The challenge will be ensuring that this wealth generates returns for workers, finances productive activities, and contributes to national development without losing sight of its fundamental purpose: guaranteeing better living conditions during retirement.

Because if longevity is changing the meaning of retirement, pensions will have to change as well. Reaching retirement with accumulated money will no longer suffice; that money will have to be made to last as long as the life it must finance.

Jupiter AM Appoints William López and Selina Tyler Co-Heads of Client Group

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Photo courtesy

Jupiter Asset Management has announced the appointment of William Lopez and Selina Tyler as Co-Heads of its Client Group, effective January 1, 2027. According to the asset manager, Selina joined Jupiter in the spring of 2025 as Head of UK and has since restructured and revitalized the British team, while strengthening and developing key strategic client relationships. Selina will continue leading the UK market—Jupiter’s largest business—and will also assume leadership of the Client Experience and Market Intelligence teams.

Meanwhile, William joined Jupiter in 2018, initially assuming responsibility for the Latin America business and subsequently for Iberia, before also taking over oversight of broader European markets last year. Both have made a significant impact on Jupiter’s market presence and in driving the turnaround currently evident across the firm. Furthermore, William will focus on the higher-growth businesses outside the UK (Europe, Asia, and the Americas) and will also lead Jupiter’s Institutional and Client Solutions teams.

In addition to these 2 changes, Jupiter also announces that Maximilian Guenzl will transition into the newly created role of Chief Strategy Officer. Max has completed 3 successful years at the helm of the Client Group, transforming how Jupiter engages with its clients and fostering the positive momentum currently seen across the entire firm. According to the firm, in this new position, Guenzl will leverage his deep understanding of Jupiter’s clients and their evolving needs to ensure the Group is strategically positioned to deliver its active management expertise to a broader client base. Moreover, he will help define and drive the Group’s strategic agenda, identifying organic and inorganic growth opportunities in a rapidly transforming environment.

Regarding these changes, Matthew Beesley, CEO of Jupiter AM, commented: “I am delighted that Selina and William are becoming Co-Heads of Jupiter’s Client Group. Both have made a real difference to the firm since joining, and their complementary experience and expertise place them in an ideal position to continue building on our positive momentum. During his 3 years leading the Client Group, Max has been instrumental in generating this momentum. Under his leadership, a transformative shift has taken place in how we engage with our clients, deepening relationships and expanding the reach of our active investment expertise. In this new phase, his insight into the rapidly evolving needs of our clients will be decisive in ensuring we are best positioned to capture the opportunities ahead.”

Following the CCLA transaction

Furthermore, Jupiter communicates that, having led the CCLA transaction and played a pivotal role in driving its integration, Peter Hugh Smith, Chief Executive Officer of CCLA, and Elizabeth Sheldon, Chief Operating Officer of CCLA, will step down from their respective roles. Peter and Liz joined CCLA in 2019 and 2011, respectively, and have overseen a period of solid growth, reshaping the entity’s operating model during a time of profound industry change.

Consequently, Andrew Robinson MBE will be appointed Executive Chair of CCLA. Since joining in 2006, Andrew has been the driving force behind CCLA’s consolidation across the UK non-profit and local authority sectors. In his new role, he will play a key part as the public face of CCLA.

“Andrew has been the visionary and architect behind CCLA’s extraordinary growth since his arrival in 2006. Thanks to his work, CCLA is recognized today as one of the leading asset managers in the UK non-profit and local authority sectors. Both Peter and Liz have been central to CCLA’s success in recent years and have played an essential role in the acquisition and integration process. Personally, I owe them a debt of gratitude for their commitment and support over the past 18 months,” Beesley added.

Global X Launches ETF with Exposure to the “Magnificent Six”

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Pixabay CC0 Public Domain

Global X announced the launch of the Global X Magnificent Six ETF (SIX), which aims to deliver exposure to the “Magnificent Six,” a cohort of technology and growth leaders currently comprising Alphabet, Amazon.com, Apple, Meta Platforms, Microsoft Corporation, and NVIDIA. The fund lists on the Cboe BZX exchange.

As an actively managed fund, SIX seeks capital appreciation through economic exposure to the companies comprising the group known as the “Magnificent Six”. Under normal market conditions, the fund invests at least 80% of its net assets, plus the amount of any borrowings for investment purposes, in securities of the “Magnificent Six” and in financial instruments and other investments providing exposure to them or collectively exhibiting economic characteristics substantially similar or equivalent to those of the “Magnificent Six” companies.

The ETF expects to gain economic exposure through swap agreements and other derivative instruments, and may also directly hold common stock of the “Magnificent Six” companies. The adviser seeks to weight the fund’s exposure by free-float market capitalization.

“These 6 companies have been a significant contributor to recent U.S. earnings growth,” said Pedro Palandrani, Head of Product Research & Development at Global X. “During the 12 months ended September 30, 2026, they contributed nearly 2/3—approximately 66%—of the earnings-per-share growth of the Bloomberg 500 Index over the trailing 12 months. Furthermore, based on current estimates, these 6 companies could invest approximately $700B in capital expenditures in 2026 and $1T in 2027, with much of that spending expected to go toward AI,” he noted.

Palandrani pointed out that the group’s combined capital expenditure positions these companies among the largest builders of AI infrastructure. “The scale of these 6 companies may enable them to reinvest at a pace few companies can match, which could help support their long-term earnings generation capacity,” he added.

Global X operates more than 30 thematic ETFs designed to invest in companies driving disruptive innovation and structural change. The lineup spans strategies ranging from infrastructure development and electrification to robotics, cybersecurity, and data centers. SIX, alongside 4 other recently launched ETFs, aims to provide allocators with targeted exposure to specialized technological and innovation segments through a single ETF vehicle.

Gold, the Asset That Shines Following the U.S. Midterm Elections

  |   By  |  0 Comentarios

Canva

Following the November 2026 U.S. midterm elections, the price of gold recorded a sharp bullish rebound, marking its best weekly performance in several months and reclaiming the psychological threshold of $4,000 per ounce. “Gold stabilized to some extent on Wednesday following Tuesday’s losses. The metal continues to find support in sustained demand from central banks. These collectively purchased 321 tons during Q3, extending an aggressive official-sector buying pattern. Robust demand could help contain any selling wave across the gold market,” notes Tim Furey, founder and CEO of Tradeview Markets & YimmiT, regarding its performance.

Taking the U.S. midterm elections as a benchmark, spot gold surged more than 3.4% in a single day during the post-election session, marking its largest daily advance since mid-August. “The metal moved from testing late-October lows near $3,870 to clearing $4,060 – $4,150 per ounce in the sessions following the vote, consolidating a weekly gain near 5%,” indicates Furey.

Catalysts behind the rally

Market experts identify the legislative gridlock produced by the election outcome as a primary catalyst for this rally. “This divided government backdrop typically narrows the runway for aggressive expansionary fiscal measures, unilateral tax cuts, or outsized debt ceiling increases, which curtailed expectations of expanding public debt,” notes Franklin Templeton.

A second driver was the pullback in Treasury yields. In this regard, expectations of reduced fiscal pressure and spending restraint exerted downward pressure on U.S. sovereign debt yields. This lowered the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets, directly benefiting bullion.

Lastly, analysts point toward an easing of geopolitical risk. Post-election signals indicated a lower probability of abrupt near-term trade or military escalations, mitigating pressure on energy commodities such as crude oil and dampening inflation concerns that might otherwise compel the Federal Reserve (Fed) to tighten monetary policy further.

Outlook for gold

When assessing the trajectory for gold, the $4,000 level has established itself as the critical support benchmark. “Our projections for gold indicate prices approaching $4,800 per ounce by Q3 2027. We expect this recovery to support silver given its precious metal characteristics and investment demand. However, industrial weakness will likely temper silver’s participation in this advance,” states Nitesh Shah, Head of Commodities and Investment Strategists at WisdomTree.

For Ned Naylor-Leyland, gold and silver fund manager at Jupiter AM, the structural case for gold—and silver—remains intact. He explains that “the secular trend toward fiat currency debasement relative to gold, expanding central bank balance sheets, and de-dollarization is deeply entrenched and persistent. Rather than viewing gold as a productive asset, I regard it as a risk-free monetary unit that preserves purchasing power as fiat currencies depreciate over time.”